Learning Center

Costs & Contracts

How to compare three contractor bids properly

Three bids land. One is $4,000 under the others. The instinct is to take it. The instinct is usually wrong, because the cheapest bid is very often the shortest scope, and you find that out in week three, not at signing.

Contractor bids, a handwritten checklist, a tape measure and glasses on a kitchen counter

A bid isn't a price for a job. It's a price for the part of the job that contractor chose to write down. Comparing totals without comparing scope compares two different projects. (If you're still working out what the job involves, start with what each common modification involves.)

The total is the least useful number on the page

Two contractors can both bid "bathroom to curbless shower" and mean entirely different things. One priced a recessed subfloor, full membrane, relocated drain and door widening. The other priced a pan replacement, a glass panel and paint. The second is cheaper because it's smaller.

The only fair comparison is line by line, against a scope you wrote. So write it first.

Build a scope sheet before you request bids

Sit down with the OT report or your own list and number every item: what's demolished, what's installed, what's patched, what's excluded. Include the dull compliance items: permits, inspections, waterproofing, electrical sign-off, haul-away, patching floors and ceilings. Our worksheets and checklists help you build a scope sheet from the OT report.

Send the identical sheet to all three. Ask each to price every line, including lines they think are unnecessary, and to flag disagreements rather than silently dropping items.

This does two things: it forces itemization, and it gives you a document to hold a contractor to. Anyone who won't bid against a written scope is telling you something.

Normalize before you judge

Put the three side by side in a spreadsheet, one row per scope line. Where a bid has no price, mark "not included", not zero. Add the missing items at a realistic cost to get a comparison total. The gap between headline and comparison price is the real story, and it's often the entire difference between bids.

Watch for:

  • Allowances. A $1,500 tile allowance means the contractor expects to spend about that. Ask what happens when it's more, and who signs the increase.
  • Unit prices. Named fixtures at cost plus margin. Check the named products match your spec.
  • Change order rates. An hourly rate and markup buried in the terms becomes the price of everything that changes.
  • "By others." Whatever's marked that way is yours. Cost it out and find who's doing it.

Exclusions worth asking about

Read all three exclusion lists, then ask each contractor the same question: what's missing here that this job will need?

Check specifically for:

  • Permits and inspections: who pulls, who pays, whether inspection delays are built in.
  • Structural work: headers, joist cutting, subfloor repair. Ask outright whether the price assumes any.
  • Waterproofing: membrane, flood test, certification.
  • Electrical: new circuits, exhaust fan, heat lamp, sign-off.
  • Plumbing: drain relocation, new vent, the difference between reusing and moving a waste line.
  • Patching: drywall, paint, flooring outside the work area, exterior repair.
  • Debris removal and dumpster.
  • Protection: dust walls, floor protection on the route, furniture covering.
  • Access: scaffolding, lift, parking permits.
  • Occupancy: whether the price assumes an empty house, and the cost if not.
  • Lead paint and asbestos: testing, RRP compliance, abatement, disposal. Any pre-1978 home triggers this.
  • Contingency: whether there is one, and how much.

A contractor who can't answer these cleanly isn't having a paperwork problem. The price is a guess.

Licensing, insurance and compliance

Three documents before you go further with anyone:

  • State or local license number, verified on the licensing board's lookup. Confirm the classification covers this work. Licensing is state and local, never federal, and some states barely regulate, so verify locally.
  • General liability certificate of insurance, at the limit your state treats as standard, dated this month, naming you as certificate holder.
  • Workers' comp, or a valid exemption. If an uninsured helper falls off a ladder, this is the document that matters.

Then the compliance trail: permits pulled by the licensed contractor (a permit in your own name as owner-builder usually makes you legally responsible for the work), EPA Lead-Safe RRP certification for pre-1978 work, and inspection sign-offs at completion. Ask who produces each. Vagueness means the work is running outside the inspection system, and you wear that at resale and at claim time. The guidebook covers licenses, insurance and RRP certification in more detail.

Payment terms, retainage and change orders

Deposits of 10 to 30% are common; more than a third before work starts warrants questions. In California, state law caps the down payment on a home improvement contract at 10% or $1,000, whichever is less. Progress payments should attach to completed, inspectable stages, not dates. Hold retainage of 5 to 10% until final inspection and punch list, and say so in the contract.

The change order clause is the most expensive paragraph you'll sign. It should require written, priced change orders approved before work proceeds, at the rates in the schedule. No verbal instructions to crews, no "we'll settle up at the end." Ask each contractor what their change order process is; whoever has a clear answer has thought about it. The guidebook explains contract terms, change orders and retainage.

Ask for conditional lien waivers with each progress payment and a final unconditional waiver at closeout, plus lien releases from major subs and suppliers. In most states an unpaid sub can lien your house even if you paid the general contractor in full.

If you're signing in your home after a door-knock or a sales visit, the FTC cooling-off rule generally gives you three business days to cancel. Never let a "today only" discount outrun it.

Red flags that survive a good price

  • A one-page bid with a single total.
  • Pressure to sign this week, or a discount that expires.
  • No physical address, or a cell number only.
  • Reluctance to give you the last three clients.
  • A cash discount with no invoice.
  • A scope that mirrors your brief exactly with no questions and nothing added. Nobody who actually looked at the job agrees with all of it.

Ask all three, identically

Who's on site day to day, employees or subs? Start date and realistic duration? Two biggest risks in this job? What have you assumed that might not hold? Who handles callbacks, and for how long?

Then call the references and ask the only question that matters: did the final invoice match the bid, and would you hire them again?

Deciding

Price is one of four factors. The others are scope completeness, demonstrated competence on this exact work, and how they handled your questions. The contractor who priced the full sheet, answered the exclusion list and handed you a clean contract is offering what a lower number can't: a job that finishes near the number on the page.

Choose on that. Get the contract reviewed before signing, and don't let a start date rush you past exclusions you haven't had answered. If paying for the work is the open question, read funding home modifications in the right order.

More in this series